Every MYGA locks your money up for a set term, but almost none of them lock all of it up. Most contracts carve out a free withdrawal provision: an amount you can take out each year without a surrender charge. Two products with identical rates can offer very different access, so it's one of the first things worth checking after the headline number. Here's how these provisions work and what they really mean for your money.
What a Free Withdrawal Provision Is
A surrender charge is the penalty for taking out more than the contract allows before the term ends. The free withdrawal provision is the part you're allowed to take out without that penalty. Everything above it is subject to the surrender schedule (and, on some contracts, a market value adjustment). Our surrender charges explainer covers the penalty side; this post is about the free side.
The Two Common Designs
- Percentage-based free withdrawals. The most common version lets you take out a set percentage of your account value each year, commonly up to 10%, starting after the first contract year. Some carriers calculate it on the current account value and others on the original deposit, and some only allow it once a year.
- Interest-only withdrawals. Some contracts let you take out the interest the contract has credited, without touching principal, and some of those allow it right away, even in year one. For someone who wants a steady cash flow from a MYGA, this is the feature that matters most.
Some contracts combine both: interest available immediately, plus a percentage-based amount after the first year. Always check the contract's exact wording, since the percentage, the base it's calculated on, and the timing all vary by carrier and product.
What It Looks Like in Dollars
| Illustration: $100,000 deposit at 6.00% compound | Amount |
|---|---|
| Account value after year 1 | $106,000 |
| 10% free withdrawal available in year 2 | $10,600 |
| Account value after taking it | $95,400 |
| Interest-only alternative, year 1 (about $500 a month) | $6,000 |
The illustration is simplified and uses a hypothetical rate. The point is the tradeoff: money you withdraw stops earning for you, so a larger withdrawal means slower growth afterward. If you only need the interest, an interest-only withdrawal leaves your principal growing. You can model both approaches in our MYGA calculator, including the income view.
Free Doesn't Mean Tax-Free
- Non-qualified (after-tax) money: withdrawals are generally treated as interest first, taxed as ordinary income, before you start getting your original deposit back. If you're under 59½, the IRS can also add a 10% additional tax on the taxable portion, subject to exceptions.
- Qualified (IRA) money: withdrawals are generally fully taxable as ordinary income, and the same early-withdrawal rules apply under 59½.
The free withdrawal provision only protects you from the carrier's surrender charge. It has no effect on what you owe in taxes. Our annuity taxation overview goes through this in more detail.
Other Ways Money Can Come Out
- Required minimum distributions. Many contracts allow RMDs from qualified annuities without a surrender charge, even above the normal free amount. Check how your contract handles it, and see our RMD guide.
- Waivers. Some contracts waive surrender charges for confined-care or terminal-illness events. These vary widely, usually have specific qualification rules, and are not automatic, so read the rider language rather than assuming.
- Death benefit. Most contracts pay the account value to beneficiaries without a surrender charge. See what happens to an annuity when the owner dies.
Questions to Ask Before You Buy
- When does the free withdrawal start: immediately, or after the first year?
- Is it interest-only, a percentage, or both?
- Is the percentage based on current account value or the original deposit?
- Can I take it monthly, or only once a year? Does unused free withdrawal carry over?
- Does a withdrawal above the free amount trigger a market value adjustment as well as a surrender charge?
- Are RMDs treated as free withdrawals?
The takeaway: A MYGA's rate tells you what you'll earn. Its free withdrawal provision tells you how much of that you can actually reach on your own schedule. Two contracts at the same rate can differ meaningfully here, which is why the rate is only the headline.
This article is for educational purposes only and is not tax or legal advice. Free withdrawal terms, surrender schedules, and tax treatment vary by carrier, product, state, and individual circumstances. Dollar figures are hypothetical illustrations and not guarantees of any specific product. Guarantees are backed by the claims-paying ability of the issuing insurance carrier.
Questions about your own situation? Contact Devin for a free, no-pressure conversation. Licensed in multiple states. No commitment required.